Home Depot's Next CEO Sold $2.1 Million of Stock in August
Richard McPhail becomes Home Depot CEO on Nov 23. In August he exercised and sold 5,989 shares for $2.1 million. Here is what the Form 4 really says.
Home Depot’s next CEO sold $2.1 million of stock in August. Today he got the top job.
On November 17, Home Depot filed an 8-K naming CFO Richard McPhail as its next CEO, effective November 23, 2026. Ann-Marie Campbell becomes President and COO, Jordan Broggi becomes CFO, and Ted Decker steps down as CEO but stays on as Chair.
Every headline today covers who got the job. Fewer cover what the new CEO did with his own shares. Three months ago, on August 19, McPhail sold 5,989 Home Depot shares at an average of $348.40, about $2.1 million.
What the 8-K says
McPhail, 56, joined Home Depot in 2005 and has been CFO since September 2019. He ran the finance side of the HD Supply, SRS Distribution and GMS acquisitions. Decker, 63, took a temporary medical leave in August, has since returned, and will remain Chair.
The 8-K also sets the new pay. McPhail gets a $1.5 million base salary, an annual bonus target of 200% of salary, a fiscal 2027 equity target of $11.5 million, and a one-time $1.5 million stock option grant that vests over three years. That is about $16 million a year at target, before the one-time grant.
The same morning, Home Depot reported third-quarter sales of $43.4 billion, up 4.9%, with comparable sales up 2.2% and adjusted EPS of $3.86.
What the August Form 4 says
Here is the trade, line by line. On August 19, McPhail exercised 5,989 stock options at a strike price of $147.36. Those options were fully vested and set to expire in March 2027. The same day he sold the same 5,989 shares at a weighted average of $348.40.
So is it a red flag?
Not on its own. This was an exercise-and-sell of old options, not a decision to dump shares he had bought. He paid about $0.9 million to exercise and sold for about $2.1 million, a pre-tax gain of roughly $1.2 million on options that had seven months left to live.
He also kept most of his stake. After the sale he still held about 48,100 Home Depot shares directly, roughly $16.7 million at today’s $347.51. The sale was about 11% of his direct position. We could not confirm a 10b5-1 plan on the filing, so treat it as a discretionary trade.
The timing is the part worth weighing. The sale came one week after Decker’s medical leave began on August 12, when McPhail and Campbell were sharing the interim leadership. It also came the day after second-quarter results, which is when executive trading windows normally open. Both things are true at once, and the filing does not tell you which one mattered more.
The 8-K tells you who got the job. The Form 4 tells you what they did with their own money before they got it.
The misconception: “net selling” means insiders are dumping
NexusAlert shows Home Depot insider net flow at negative $14.4 million across 71 transactions, with 8 Form 144 notices on file. That number sounds alarming. It is also a blend of very different things.
Look at the notable lines. Decker’s two largest entries, $2.3 million and $1.5 million on March 1, are tax withholding: shares the company held back to cover taxes when stock vested. Nobody chose to sell those. That is about $3.8 million of the total before you get to a single discretionary trade.
The bigger pattern
Home Depot’s Company scores show the real tension. Insider Conviction is 1.5 out of 10, in the bottom 15% of companies NexusAlert scores, because insider selling has far outweighed insider buying over the past year. Institutional Flow is 9.9, in the top 1%, a sign that institutional money has been moving in.
That is not a contradiction. Executives at mature companies are paid largely in stock and sell some of it on a routine basis, while funds make their own call on the business. The honest read is that McPhail’s August sale is consistent with that routine, and that his new package will hand him far more stock than he sold.
One insider sale is noise. What you want to watch now is what the new CEO does next. A first open-market buy after November 23 would say more than anything in today’s 8-K.
The lesson
The headline gives you the name. The Form 4 gives you the behavior. Before you decide how you feel about a new CEO, read what they traded as an insider, check the transaction code, and separate tax withholding from real sales.
Read the whole filing, not the headline. NexusAlert flagged the succession 8-K the morning it was filed and puts the new CEO’s full insider record on the same page.
Create a free NexusAlert account
Sources
- Home Depot Form 8-K, CEO succession and compensation terms, filed Nov 17, 2026, SEC EDGAR
- Home Depot press release, Richard McPhail named CEO effective Nov 23, 2026 (Exhibit 99.1), SEC EDGAR
- Home Depot third quarter fiscal 2026 results (Exhibit 99.1), SEC EDGAR
- Home Depot CFO sells 5,989 shares at $348.40, StockTitan Form 4 summary
- McPhail Richard V insider transactions, SECForm4
- Home Depot names finance chief McPhail as CEO, Reuters via Investing.com
- Home Depot names Richard McPhail as new CEO, beats earnings expectations, CNBC
- Home Depot CEO Ted Decker takes medical leave, Retail TouchPoints
- NexusAlert Alerts and Company Dossier for HD
Prefer to own it outright? NexusAlert lifetime access is available for a one-time payment of $299 — no subscription, no recurring charges, all future Pro features included. Learn more →